to weather or not, that is the question ! F-4 Phantom on the cover of Model Aircraft Monthly

I don't do 'opinion' pieces. Much. Too frightened of upsetting my readers I guess. But I thought I'd 'kill two birds with one stone' in this post. Great looking F-4 on the cover of the current issue of Model Aircraft Monthly. Depending on your point of view that is hopelessly over-done shading and other 'arty' effects - or not. One from the 'Spanish School' of super modelling. And the 'new' Model Aircraft Monthly, apparently another triumph of style over substance! Never in the field of modelling journalism has so much white space been seen in so few pages! And then I've been wanting to post a response to a "Weathering Rant" on Jon B's 'Combat Workshop' blog..

Now, I'm not against 'weathering' at all- that would be silly! But I do not for one moment agree with those recent blog posts from a couple of US modellers stating that weathering is "an essential part" of modelling. Their assumption that 'weathered' vs. 'clean' model aircraft are somehow much more 'realistic' rather irked me.

Now don't get me wrong I don't mind a bit of weathering. I will even occasionally introduce some - hopefully- subtle airbrush effects help to blur the line between 'plastic toy replica' and 'scale model'. If I didn't I'd probably just be happy with a new die-cast. Although how one can be happy with paying a small fortune for a block of metal featuring huge trench lines and a 'toy' finish hand-painted by some Chinese slave worker who has never seen a real aeroplane in his/her life is beyond me - £250 for a metal 32nd scale Bf 109 ?...no way. I've always said to myself, the day a die-cast looks as good as one of my finished models is probably the day I put the stash on ebay. But that's another rant!

 Back to weathering. Lets face it, there are those extreme 'weatherers' out there who probably use every product going - Mig, AK you name it. Some so-called 'super modellers' have turned this into an entire aftermarket industry - presumably nice little earners they are too! While trying of course to persuade us that we need their products to make 'proper' models. That special effect you used to be able to create with oils, pastels, chalks and other media is now most of the time available straight out of a (very expensive) little bottle!

The other problem that I have with most extreme "weatherers" is that they tend to lose all notion of 'scale realism' and get totally carried away with creating a replica that -in their eyes- is closer to 'artwork'. Get on with applying those MiG powders, AK pastes and God knows what else and totally lose all notion of 'scale effect' - exhaust stains, chipping, rust, mostly invisible to the eye had the real thing been scaled down to 72, 48th, 32nd or whatever. So much more superior than the straight forward OOB guys. Now I don't really want to get into the 'psychology' of weathering. but it seems to me that merely 'assembling' and constructing a plastic 'toy model' for the extreme 'weatherer' is a slightly shameful thing. Their aim ultimately is to disguise the fact that they stick pre-formed pieces of plastic together. Of course you can argue that this is the 'purpose' of a good model. To try and hide the fact that it is a model. Especially as any Tom, Dick or Harry can do it. So you have to 'disguise' what you do by dressing it up as 'art'. The 'extreme weatherer' is rarely capable of building a scale model and replicating what can be seen in a photo, they need to be Michelangelo in their own Sistine Chapel. You can see why some modellers appear to get totally carried away more often than not, giving free reign to their 'artistic' sensibilities.

Now of course I'm being slightly tongue-in-cheek there! I have little chance of ever producing anything as superb looking as this F-4. But it does look 'wrong' to me - besides it is a 72nd scale kit rather blown up. My forthcoming Corsair will definitely need some weathering to stand any chance of looking half 'realistic'. But in the end I shall probably just settle for a bit of an oil wash, some pre and post-shading, maybe some 'salt' weathering over the wings. Each to his own. But then of course it won't appear on the cover of a magazine...

Stunning new Tooby Airfix artwork and reactivating a couple of part-started builds, Revell Corsair, Airfix Fw 190, Academy Bf 109 G-14 in 72nd

nice day in the garden again ..and clearing some more part-started builds from the bench hopefully. I'm not that keen on reactivating part-started builds to be honest - I find that working up enthusiasm for them is hard work, but as it's a nice day and I'm on nights later on I'm just looking for something to fettle and tinker with in the sunshine...mind you if I can finish these this month, that will be a record five completions for the month! The Airfix Fw 190 I'm building as a night fighting 'Porcupine' of JG 300 - just adding some wire antennae having drilled out some holes on the wings and fuselage. The Academy G-14 to be finished as Hartmann's JG 53 Kommandeur machine should be a G-6...

Fantastic RIAT - Royal International Air Tattoo, RAF Fairford, England 6-10 July

See my 'Jet & Prop' blog for some coverage of this fantastic air show, featuring a variety of 2nd, 3rd, 4th and fifth generation fighter aircraft all on the same airfield - the past, present and future of air combat...links on the side panel

Zvezda Junkers Ju 88 G-6 in 72nd scale (4)

Two completions inside a week. Well its been a few months since I was last able to get to a club meeting and since I knew I was going to be able to go to July's I was very keen to take along something new. This is my Zvezda Junkers Ju 88 G-6 night fighter in 72nd scale with the addition of resin Jumo engines, exhausts and spinners from AIMS. The engines feature finer detail and perfectly engraved supercharger intakes. I have built this model as a representation of Eduard Lindinger's machine -see below.

Below; seen here after an undercarriage malfunction on landing at Lueneberg in early 1945 this is 'C9+ET' flown by Ofw. Eduard Lindinger of NJG 5. This 9. Staffel machine is fitted with a 'shortened' 2cm SM installation and single MG 131. Note the cabin roof-mounted Naxos - and the re-located upward-firing SM installation. And I can see now that I've missed the 'old-style' solid fuselage Balkenkreuz. Wasn't expecting that on a late-war G-6!

Lindinger was awarded the Ritterkreuz for 300+ sorties in KG 1 but enjoyed a singular lack of success as a night fighter - he returned no night victories while in III./NJG 5. Lindinger died on 1 September 2004.

..and, below, on the club table for the July meet...

Airfix new-tool Junkers Ju 87 B-1 Stuka - in-box build review finished (2)

My completed new-tool Airfix Junkers Ju 87 B-1 in 72nd scale finished in the new Humbrol Luftwaffe enamels in the markings of a StG 51 machine. A nice simple build and finish. Looks a little 'toy-like' to me, perhaps those over scale panel lines on the wings don't help. No swastikas on the decal sheet. Some of the smaller parts are impossible to get off the sprues without breaking them, especially the bomb 'sling'..

And a link to the Academy and Italeri 72nd scale Stukas on this blog here

Airfix new-tool Junkers Ju 87 B-1 Stuka - in-box build review

A few views of my new-tool Airfix Stuka B-1 build in 72nd. The kit is very neatly molded and assembles easily enough. A relatively trouble-free, if not to say painless build! The cockpit is a little sparse on detail - certainly not as good as Academy's Ju 87 G-2 in this scale - and the 'one-piece' span length aileron/flaps are a little inaccurate and tricky to line-up and probably need glueing in two stages. Just the decals and a few finishing touches to go..